Canceling Culture.

Whew! We’ve finally boot-kicked 2020 to where it belongs – the rear view mirror. Everyone’s circumstances were different, and thus, one’s means of coping varied – (bourbon, anyone?) My personal long distance memory of it might eventually be summed up in the T.S. Eliot quote:

“Books. Cats. Life is good.”


There were times so distracting this past year that I actually couldn’t read and had to settle for the therapy of petting cats. But eventually, books once again became the magic carpet ride that they’ve always been, transporting me to different times, different places, different ways of looking at the world. Books are, for me, truly a lifeline.

Thus, when the following tweet popped, unbidden, across my timeline, I could only think WHAT FRESH HELL IS THIS?


I’m not one of the cool kids, so, while I’m familiar with cancel culture, #DisruptTexts had thus far mercifully eluded me. The gist of it seems to be that everything written prior to 2019 and lacking a woke label and especially a classic and most especially anything written by a “white” male, belongs in a great big bonfire. To Kill a Mockingbird was on the cancel list this year, as was Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn. Go figure. Twain’s stand against bigotry was compelling enough that he basically denounced his own father. It was Twain’s long friendship with John T. Lewis that inspired the character of Jim in the classic tale:


But never mind that. While there might be hope on the horizon for COVID inoculation, there does not appear to be a vaccine for stupidity.

I understand that a great cheer will go up from high schoolers who will now be spared the punishment of Homer’s epic. I well remember the misery of my own high school years – in my case, torture was assigned in the form of Milton’s Paradise Lost, which, if I remember correctly, makes The Odyssey seem like light reading in comparison.

I re-read (voluntarily!) The Iliad and The Odyssey a few years back and found them to be absolutely transcendent. I do understand that they may not be everybody’s cup of tea. The Roman emperor Caligula was, in fact, the first to ban The Odyssey because it expressed “dangerous Greek ideals of freedom”. Well, there you go.

Caligula, like ourselves, was caught up in his cultural moment. It is inescapable. None of us can truly rise above it. The classics, I would argue though, might be one means of mitigating the most pernicious effects of the echo chamber each one of us – regardless of our mindset – inhabits. Maybe, just maybe that’s why “they” want to ban them?

More than one pundit, in response to the Odyssey kerfuffle, has admonished readers to invest in hardcover copies of classic history and fiction because, as the Twitter account @chigirl claims, “the internet is erasing history“. If you doubt the veracity of her words, you might want to read up on the ferocious and relentless ways in which Wikipedia editors are cutting, embroidering, slanting and essentially re-writing Western history. A 1990-era set of Encyclopedia Britannica might be an interesting acquisition to make right now. “Reference books” could take on a whole new meaning as we go forward.

Next week I’ll begin the annual reading retrospective, but of course I’m already looking forward to the delicious “menu” of books to read in this new year. You can bet that a re-read of The Odyssey is on it, thanks to Ms. Heather Levine. If you wish to join me, I recommend the Fagles translation. Buy the paperback, just in case…


My other reading goals are to scoop up more and more “classic” works because I truly believe they matter. Just as we all should be exposed to books that take us out of our echo chambers – aren’t we all guilty of seeking more and more of what aligns with our world view? – we benefit by reading the works that, sifting down through time, have earned the stamp of a “classic”. Because we are simply fools if we make the mistake of thinking our “cultural moment” is culture.


About polloplayer

Empty nester searching for meaning of life through the occasional chicken epiphany.
This entry was posted in Books and Reading, Life and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Canceling Culture.

  1. dizzyguy says:

    Hard not to notice the many eerie similarities between current wokesters and the fascists they claim to despise. First amendment is under serious attack, with many classic publications being targeted. This is part of an effort to obliterate our culture and history and replace it with one that is acceptable to the intolerant little tyrants we see popping up everywhere, competing with each other to be the wokest. But fear not, Mark Twain will be around making fun of them, even long after they are all gone.

  2. Smiler says:

    Thank you for this post. I read 1984 in higher school in… 1984. Animal Farm has been a longtime favourite I like to return to now and again. “All pigs are equal, but some pigs are more equal than other” has always chilled me to the bone and now they’re insisting this is so.

    Since 2016, I’ve felt trapped in those dystopias & somehow things got worse when the left (which I used to “identify” with) decided to up the ante with this woke cancel culture madness. It’s gotten so bad I’m having trouble holding on to sanity & my therapist advised me to stay away from millennial authors calling people “privileged” & “cis” & stick to classics insteas & one of my favourite genres, historical fiction (not written by those trying to rewrite a woke history of the world — no Broadchurch on Netflix for me, thanks).

    I refuse to be made irrelevant. I’m GenX. We fought against harmful labels. Canceling the Odyssey. I studied the Greeks in an open school setting which was one of my most satisfying learning experiences in college. These children don’t know a thing about history. To them, the 20th century is simply unwoke and not worthy of taking valuable lessons from on the dangers of authoritarianism. It’s terrifying. Plenty of reading, my dog Charley (all 7lbs of him) my cat Mimi & loads of sleep with both cuddling up with me are getting me through this so-called cultural Marxist-Maoist moment. Also, relatively sane people on Twitter & on the internet (“sane” having taken on a whole new meaning, along with so many words & concepts); people grounded in reality exist. Thank heavens.

  3. citymama says:

    this is a powerful post and i’m trying to squash my anger. it’s getting harder and harder to do so. maybe we should ask pelosi what we are supposed to call our parents because evidently “father” and “mother” are no longer acceptable.

    my goodness when will the “woke” wake up.

    long live classics. 👊🏻

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s